Deer Management

This webpage was created to provide information about white-tailed deer (Odocoileus virginianus), strategies for managing the deer population, damage prevention and abatement techniques, public health and safety information, what to do about injured or orphaned deer, and information about the role you can play in managing the City of Batavia’s deer population.

Citizens have varying interests regarding deer. Some are concerned about deer-vehicle accidents or damage to landscaping or crops, while others enjoy hunting, photographing, or watching deer.  The numerous, and often conflicting, views on how they should be managed makes the task challenging. The cooperation of landowners and land managers, as well as cooperation among neighbors, is essential to maintaining deer numbers at acceptable levels.  A “good neighbor” philosophy is not something that can be mandated, but such a view is essential to successful deer management.

ABOUT THE WHITE-TAILED DEER

According to National Geographic, white-tailed deer, the smallest members of the North American deer family, are found from southern Canada to South America. In the heat of summer they typically inhabit fields and meadows using clumps of broad-leaved and coniferous forests for shade. During the winter they generally keep to forests, preferring coniferous stands that provide shelter from the harsh elements.

Breeding

Adult white-tails have reddish-brown coats in summer which fade to a duller grayish-brown in winter. Male deer, called bucks, are easily recognizable in the summer and fall by their prominent set of antlers, which are grown annually and fall off in the winter. Only the bucks grow antlers, which bear a number of tines, or sharp points. During the mating season, also called the rut, bucks fight over territory by using their antlers in sparring matches.

Female deer, called does, give birth to one to three young at a time, usually in May or June and after a gestation period of seven months. Young deer, called fawns, wear a reddish-brown coat with white spots that helps them blend in with the forest.

Diet and Behavior

White-tailed deer are herbivores, leisurely grazing on most available plant foods. Their stomachs allow them to digest a varied diet, including leaves, twigs, fruits and nuts, grass, corn, alfalfa, and even lichens and other fungi. Occasionally venturing out in the daylight hours, white-tailed deer are primarily nocturnal or crepuscular, browsing mainly at dawn and dusk.

In New York, white-tails, particularly the young, are preyed upon by bobcats, black bears, and coyotes. They use speed and agility to outrun predators, sprinting up to 30 miles per hour and leaping as high as 8-10 feet and as far as 30 feet in a single bound.

Impacts from Deer

White-tailed deer are high-profile animals and among the country’s most popular wildlife species. While most will agree they are beautiful and appreciate their presence, they can have their negative side as well, and when too plentiful, especially in an urban or suburban setting, they can become a nuisance. White-tailed deer are highly adaptable and that adaptability allows them to thrive amongst humans. Furthermore, in many highly-developed areas where hunting does not occur, deer can begin to lose their fear of humans, further exacerbating problems like landscaping damage and vehicle collisions.  Deer are also reproductively prolific, and in the absence of hunting their numbers can quickly get out of hand.  That said, it is not the number of deer per se that is the problem, but the negative impacts they cause. Any plan to address the negative impacts of deer should take this into account, and progress toward goals should be measured by the reduction of impacts, not necessarily the reduction of the number of deer.

What Is the City of Batavia Doing?

The City is currently studying the deer population concerns in the City to determine if steps need to be taken to reduce future impacts from the deer population. The City Council has created the Deer Management Committee to conduct this study and review of the City’s deer population.  Residents have been appointed to the committee, and support is being provided by City staff and the New York State Department of Environmental Conservation. This approach includes:

  • Conducting a resident deer survey to gauge interests and determine if there is a deer population problem in the City.

  • Reviewing existing literature, reference material and best practices regarding community-based deer management techniques.

  • Reviewing the cost estimate methodology, costs for each alternative, discussing un-anticipated cost areas and contingencies and researching possible funding sources.

  • Making a recommendation to City Council no later than July 1, 2017.

The challenge for government officials is to find an acceptable balance between the presence of deer in the city and the associated risk to people and their property. We will never get rid of all the deer within the City limits. People and deer can coexist so long as impacts from deer populations are managed at an acceptable level.

Some Tips for White-tailed Deer Coexistence